- YUK CHAI team from Petaling Jaya
- Woodgrove team from Singapore
My extreme superficial thoughts had actually kept me away from knowing more about refugees. Before this, both refugees and foreign workers are indifferent to me. Both parties come here with the same purpose, for a better living, either successful or not.
In the lesson lectured by Ms. Shanti from UNHCR, here I get some basic knowledge regarding refugees. Normally, refugees do not get to choose, they flee from their country to seek for safety and hoping for a protection in other country; and some of them may cheated by irresponsible agents to come to here and forced to stay. After knowing their situation, here I come to empathy on them.
But when Ms. Shanti ‘yelling’ for the rights of refugees in Malaysia, I started to question: why should we give them the rights in Malaysia? Yes, they are helpless and yes, they flee to Malaysia hoping for some protection, but hey, Malaysia is not that strong enough to even take care of their local residences, why should we still have to care for others? A question from my friend interrupted my thinking. “Try to think if you are them, what you would do if you are in such a situation”. “I would rather stay and die in my own country” I answered without a second thought.
I keep that thought with me until I experience the similar situation by myself. Yesterday I involved in a minor car accident and chased by a taxi driver. To run away from him, I drive myself into an unknown place, get down from my car intended to run to some places with crowd, hoping for some protection, or at least to hide myself away from being seen by him. Luckily I found a ‘mamak’ stall and I take a seat which I think is invisible. I sat there for around half an hour with a glass of teh tarik, pray hard and shivers. But I feel safe at that time in that shelter, from the friendly smile of the waiters, and a greeting from one of the person in charge, from what I can recall.
After that incident, I have a mere understanding of feeling helpless especially in a place that is totally strange to one. Other than feeling glad from saving myself from the accident; I regret for what I have think so far on refugees and what I have said. I am selfish as a person. I am so engaged with myself and enjoy being in my comfort zone until I couldn’t share the privileges I have with others.
To write this reflection paper, I started to explore myself on this issue in Malaysia. Influx of foreigners has indirectly causes significant changes in Malaysia. Cheap labors have actually contributed in reducing the amount of local workers in Malaysia. Normally, foreign workers are hiring with the option of choosing for cheap payment labor and job involve in 3D, demeaning, dirty and dangerous. Nowadays, legal or illegal foreign workers are both the favorite of employers.
If refugees can hire legally in Malaysia, there will be imbalance amount of foreign and local workers in Malaysia. According to prime minister, nearly 3 million illegal foreigners get a job in Malaysia. Continuous influx of foreigners without any restriction has put the local worker in risk of losing job. There’s a saying. Greater amount of foreign workers will lead to greater suffer for local residence resulting from competing for the limited resources.
The influx of foreigners can be clearly seen around some cheap housing areas and surrounding public transport stations. To survive or live a life, they meet some friends and find their mates here in Malaysia, and some of them may start to strive for the same privilege as the local residences have it here, as far as they could. These are the phenomena commonly found in foreign workers. If refugees are allowed to come into Malaysia and find their work here legally, the same problems might occur and the problems will hence been doubled up.
Proper placement should be given to every refugee. If they are not given a job or they felt unsatisfied here, they may commit themselves in crime just to feed themselves. And if they are given legal permission to come into Malaysia and privilege to have education like normal residences, they may just be one of the Malaysian and indirectly, Malaysia may encourage more and more refugees to come over here.
Problems mentioned above may be some of the consideration of Malaysia not singing up as listed country for Convention and Protocol. UNHCR did a good job supporting people with needs, worldwide. By addressing their needs, I believe that UNHCR has solved some difficulties before some undesirable problems have actually occurred. From my personal point of view, refugees flee to Malaysia should have the rights to address their needs and given assistance in sending back to their home country; but not to encourage and support them to stay in Malaysia as an option.
yVonne